Semifinal No. 2

CROWD SURFING (JUN. 24 VS. RAYS)
Josh Donaldson leaps into the stands with reckless abandon to make a spectacular catch and keep Marco Estrada’s bid for a perfect game alive in Tampa Bay. It wasn’t a perfect game in the end, but the leap into the crowd certainly was.

CURTAIN CALL (SEPT. 27 VS. RAYS)
Yes, we already have a Josh Donaldson Division, and a Going Yard one, too. But Bringer of Rain’s walk-off shot in Toronto’s final home game of the regular season was too big an exclamation point on the MVP debate to deny him a Wild Card spot. So. Clutch.

Semifinal No. 1

HOME RUN HAT TRICK (AUG. 29 VS. TIGERS)
Not once, not twice, but thrice! Encarnacion’s three-HR, nine-RBI game was capped off with the grandest of grand slams and an extended delay as fans began throwing hats on the field. All indications from those in attendance point to it being one of the most special moments in Rogers Centre history.

PILLAR GOES SPIDER-MAN (APR. 15 VS. RAYS)
Pillar scaled the 10-foot Rogers Centre outfield wall like your friendly neighbourhood superhero to save a home run from Tampa Bay’s Tim Beckham. Buck Martinez called it one of the best catches ever from a Blue Jays outfielder.

Come back tomorrow to vote on the next head-to-head matchup.