TORONTO — Of all the Toronto Maple Leafs’ nine consecutive losses, of all eight straight on home ice, and of all 11 they’ve swallowed in their past 12 attempts, this was the ugliest.
The Leafs built a two-goal lead over the 28th-place Columbus Blue Jackets. They carried a one-goal edge deep into the contest’s 56th minute. They had struck on the power play, received a rare snipe from a blue liner and were holding strong thanks to a gymnastic performance in net by Anthony Stolarz.
The slump was all but busted.
And then…
A William Nylander giveaway led directly to a revenge goal by Matthew Knies, making his return after his trade out of Toronto.
A quicksand faceoff coverage 52 seconds later allowed Norris champ Zach Werenski to dance right to crease and roof the winner in regulation.
A previously cheery and hopeful Scotiabank Arena, which had been root-root-rooting for the home team all night, turned like mayonnaise left out on a radiator.
“Fire Hiller!” chants reigned upon Toronto’s head coach. One fan reached from the glass and tried to bless the man. Another threw a foreign object on the ice in disgust. Most just booed their despondent heroes off the ice.
Again.
“Happened quick, but it’s just inexcusable. Just can’t happen,” Auston Matthews managed. The captain’s mouth said all the right things. His eyes looked stunned more than angry.
Why does this keep happening? The freebies. The blown leads. The losses to opponents strong and weak and everything in between.
“I don't know,” Matthews said, twice. “It’s obviously been a really rough stretch here, but tonight was… I mean, we should be embarrassed, I think. I mean, it’s not fair to the people that paid tickets to come watch. Yeah, it's inexcusable. It really is.”
Thing is, Saturday’s crowd was unusually loud and positive for 55-plus minutes.
The “Stolie!” cheers were rocking when the giant goalie lunged cross-crease to rob Adam Fantilli of a power-play one-timer. Knies and fellow ex-Leaf Steven Lorentz were welcomed back warmly. And round after impressive round of The Wave toured the bowl as the Leafs never trailed… until Werenski’s dagger.
“They were engaged all game and into it and loud. I'd be pissed off too, if I was them,” said Jake McCabe, who scored his first of the season and blocked a game-high six shots. “We just threw up all over ourselves and blew the game.
“It is hard to wrap your head around, for sure.”
Nylander’s shallow behind-the-net clearing attempt, caught and dropped by Knies in the high slot, was particularly puzzling.
“That was personal for me,” Knies, smiling, said of the comeback win.
Nylander spat a four-letter word at himself as he walked to the losing room.
“It was dumb play by me, so that got them going,” he said when the cameras arrived.
“You just can’t do freebies the other way,” said Jim Hiller, his shaky voice reflective of his players’ performance.
“It's not National Hockey League level. That's frustrating for all of us. When I say all of us, I mean everybody. I mean everybody — players, media, fans, anybody. It’s hard to swallow.”
Sure, but the Maple Leafs were swallowing a cannon blast of Blue Jackets throughout the third period. The NHL’s 32nd-ranked offence outshot them 35-26 and out-attempted them 78-49.
Apply pressure, and they’ll crack.
“They were just kind of in our end, doing whatever they wanted to that whole period. So, try to hold on, try to hold on, and then they put one in, and then they put another one in,” Matthews recounted. “You're up a goal and you're maybe just playing not to lose, instead of just doing what got you the lead in in the first place.
“There's some risk that you can't take. But, I mean, it's still the same game. Like, it's still what you're doing in the first two periods. You got to chip pucks in a lot. You got to forecheck. You got to get on top of their D and stay above guys and hem them in their own zone.”
The Maple Leafs are now hemmed into a winless November. Nylander conceded that the mood “gets a bit negative” with all these bad plays and worse results.
That includes a coach who has tried scratches and line blenders and Rory McIlroy ("They're bringing the ringers!" Jackets coach Rick Bowness noted) and batting practice and extra rest and extra-long practices and psychologist sessions.
A coach who had to respond to a question about the home fans calling for his job just 25 games into his contract.
“The noise is the noise, and it's always going to be there. I understand that. You know, we got to do some soul searching here. There's no question. And we gotta get the team better prepared than we did tonight. That's the bottom line. Players play. We got to coach them, and we got to do a better job because that's not good enough,” Hiller said.
Does Hiller think he’s lost the room?
“No, I don't think that,” he replied. “Just because of my interactions with them and what I hear. That's why I feel.”
Matthews said Hiller has remained upbeat during this downturn — then took ownership himself.
“He's coaching us. And at the end of the day, we're the ones that have to go out there and play. Like, it can't be on the guy that's calling the lines out there,” Matthews said. “I mean, it's the guys that are on the ice that have to take accountability.”
When you spend the week losing to three of the worst teams in hockey, there’s plenty of blame to go around.
“I mean, we're all taking heat,” said McCabe, eating criticism like another slapshot headed his way. “That’s what happens when you lose hockey games. I got a lot of respect for Jim. I got a lot of respect for the guys in this room. We got to stick together here. That’s the only way out.”
Fox’s Fast Five
• Oliver Ekman-Larsson was scratched in favour of serviceable AHL call-up Dakota Mermis, who notched a primary assist.
The only other time Ekman-Larsson got healthy-scratched as a Leaf was near last year’s trade deadline, when GM Brad Treliving tried dealing him at peak value.
“We’ve seen O play better. Hasn’t been as good as he typically is,” Hiller said. “It’s tough. A good veteran player like that, we just need to get his game to the level that he’s used to playing. We just feel like it’s dipped a bit.”
Ekman-Larsson was Toronto’s most consistent and highest-scoring defenceman last season, posting 39 points. The 35-year-old has just one assist in 24 games this season.
He’s signed through 2027-28 at a $3.5 million cap hit.
• Good news for ex-Jacket Kirill Marchenko, who has been sidelined nearly a month with an undisclosed left knee injury. The winger’s status has been upgraded as day-to-day, making him a possibility to return during next week’s road trip.
“He’s obviously an incredible talent,” Brandon Duhaime told reporters at morning skate as Marchenko lurked nearby. “He was doing those 2-on-1s with us. He looked real good. I don’t want to pump him up too much. But, yeah, we’re lucky to have him back.”
The winger snatched team reporter Ryan Leslie’s microphone during Duhaime’s scrum and followed up: “Can you repeat about Kirill Marchenko again?”
“Elite talent, blah, blah, blah,” Duhaime replied, smiling. “Bad guy!”
• Fun fact: The Blue Jackets have the NHL’s highest percentage of goals scored by defencemen (29.6 per cent), while the Maple Leafs blue line has the lowest (7.7 per cent).
• Happy-go-lucky Lorentz is disappointed how his final days as a Leaf played out.
“It was weird the way it went down. When we got the new management, I didn’t hear from them all summer long,” Lorentz said. “After playing six years in the league, I thought you’d at least hear something.”
Still, the born-and-bred Leafs fan said he can’t put into words what it meant to wear the crest he’s spent his life rooting for: “It was a privilege and an honour.”
• As a Leaf, Knies’ most memorable fan-interaction story went down at the corner of Bay and Lakeshore:
“I came in for a game, and I almost ran someone over trying to park. They were wearing my jersey, actually. They flipped me the bird, and then I was like, 'Oh, gosh.' I don't think they even recognized who it was.”




