We’ve reached the quarter mark of the NHL season, and like most years, there are a handful of teams exceeding expectations. If you glance at the standings around mid-November, it’s not uncommon to see a few teams holding down playoff spots that you didn’t expect, and it’s no different in 2026-27.
It’s not the most difficult task in the world to have a good 20-25-game stretch, although it’s much harder to sustain that over 84 games. Teams can ride the wave of a hot goalie out of the gates or an inflated shooting percentage to put some points in the bank early in the year. A lot of the factors that propel a team to a fast start, though, often dry up as the season wears on. If teams plan to make the playoffs, they have to grab onto something sustainable to carry them through to the spring.
For this exercise, we’ll break down four teams that are either occupying a playoff spot or hovering right around the post-season cutoff line, and analyze whether they are contenders or pretenders.
In this sense, the word "contender" doesn’t necessarily mean they should be in the Stanley Cup conversation, but rather whether they have a legitimate shot at a playoff spot when we look down the road throughout a full campaign.
No Igor Shesterkin? No problem, apparently. The Rangers have raced out to 27 points and a plus-9 goal differential despite losing their best player for the season. New York currently sits third in the Metro, and only the Carolina Hurricanes have more regulation wins in the Eastern Conference than the Rangers. Some of those victories have also come against some tough competition, including outscoring the Tampa Bay Lightning 9-2 in an impressive two-game showing.
If you’re trying to hang your hat on something that’s sustainable, the Rangers rank in the top 10 in expected goals and their team shooting percentage hasn’t been overly inflated — it’s right around league average. Plus, Alexis Lafreniere looks like he’s on his way to a breakout season with 10 goals and 22 points and other top players like Adam Fox, J.T. Miller and Mika Zibanejad are playing well.
That said, if there’s reason for concern, it might be between the pipes. Dylan Garand and Joonas Korpisalo, who just returned from injury, have been excellent, but how long can they sustain their strong play? Korpisalo has a .940 save percentage in limited action this year, and he has finished well below .900 in each of the past three seasons. Meanwhile, Garand has been a great story, though he’s only played 18 career games, and it’s hard to imagine he’s ready for a significant workload and his play won’t dip along the way. The Rangers are 25th in high-danger chances allowed, so at some point Korpisalo and Garand aren’t going to be able to keep bailing them out.
There’s also going to be much harder games to come. New York hasn’t had to face Carolina yet and has only played New Jersey once, with the Devils winning 7-1. The opponents are only going to get tougher, and the best path for the Rangers to get in is by finishing in the top three in the Metro. There is a good chance five teams are making it from the Atlantic, and we fear that over a long season, the Islanders, Devils and Hurricanes will finish ahead of them.
Verdict: Pretender
The Islanders recently won three straight by a combined score of 16-5 and find themselves right back into the playoff mix. New York is two points back of both the final wild-card spot and third place in the Metro, with a game in hand on the aforementioned Rangers. They’re in a decent spot, but there are a couple of red flags.
If you look at how the Isles have stacked up against some of the league’s elite teams, it hasn’t been pretty. They’re 2-4-2 against New Jersey, Tampa Bay, Ottawa, Minnesota and Dallas, which are some of the NHL’s best this season. The Islanders have done a good job of feasting on weaker competition, but they are going to have to start beating some better teams if they want to push up the standings further. Plus, they rank 19th in expected goals, which is usually a huge problem unless your special teams are excellent. The Isles have a great penalty kill, but the power play is only ranked 28th.
Where there is reason for some long-term optimism is the fact that the Islanders are in a great spot when it comes to having difference makers at the most important positions. Bo Horvat is a legit number one centre who is scoring at a point-per-game pace and is great in all three zones. Matthew Schaefer is already one of the league’s best defencemen and is only going to get better. He’s a huge catalyst for the offence and is playing close to 27 minutes a night. Then there’s Ilya Sorokin in goal, who is one of the best in the business and a true Vezina-calibre netminder. Heading into Thursday, Sorokin had saved more than 10 goals above expected this season, good enough for fourth best in the NHL. He has the ability to compensate for some of the Islanders' shortcomings.
New York also has the benefit of a great head coach. Pete DeBoer is in his first full season with the Isles and is known for squeezing the most out of his roster. His teams always play with great structure, perform well in big games and frequently go deep in the playoffs. In a wide-open division outside of Carolina and New Jersey, that gives the Isles a big edge.
Verdict: Contender
It’s been a tale of two seasons for the Jets. After a nine-game losing streak put their season in jeopardy very early on, a few monumental four-goal comebacks sparked six wins in a row to get Winnipeg right back in the hunt. The Jets are fortunate to play in the West, where the post-season cutoff line figures to be much lower than in the East. So, thanks to that recent surge, Winnipeg is still very much in the mix.
The Jets have some elite talent at the top of their lineup that can carry them at times. Mark Scheifele scored over 100 points last season and is on pace for 106 this season, and Kyle Connor continues to prove he’s one of the league’s best goal scorers. Connor has already scored 18 times and seems destined to set a new career high in goals. Cole Perfetti is also off to a really hot start and looks to be in the middle of a breakout season. A now-healthy Josh Morrissey should also provide a huge boost.
What’s challenging for Winnipeg is getting enough out of the rest of the lineup to really make an impact. Players like Viggo Bjorck and Brayden Yager should be great building blocks for the future, but they are unlikely to make meaningful contributions this season. The Jets also don’t stand out in any particular area, ranking 20th in goal scoring, 12th in goals against, ninth on the power play and 24th on the penalty kill. All that translates to a pretty average team that you can expect to be pretty streaky over the course of 84 games.
It would also be remiss not to point out what a huge loss Connor Hellebuyck is. Winnipeg is 24th in team save percentage, and its goaltending isn’t going to be able to steal them many games. It certainly doesn’t help that the Jets are also in a very talented division with the likes of Colorado, Dallas, Minnesota and Utah, so it’s going to be a real uphill climb for the Jets to sneak in.
Verdict: Pretender
Most people felt the Predators would likely be retooling or rebuilding this season. Instead, Nashville is sitting in the first wild card spot in the West and two points back of Colorado for third in the Central Division. New general manager Chris MacFarland added more depth throughout the roster with players like Jack Drury, Ross Colton and Shane Wright, and it’s working so far.
That’s all well and good, but it’s been the veterans who are driving play. Roman Josi has scored over a point per game after missing significant time in each of the past two seasons, and Ryan O’Reilly isn’t showing any signs of slowing down. The Steven Stamkos signing, which didn’t look so great in year one, now looks like solid value. Stamkos can still find the back of the net with the best of them and is on pace for 46 goals this season. Juuse Saros also appears to be having a renaissance in goal, sitting sixth in the NHL in goals saved above expected and top 10 when it comes to save percentage.
However, a look under the hood paints a picture that isn’t as rosy. Nashville is 21st in expected goals at around 48 per cent, and only seven teams have allowed more high-danger chances than the Predators. Saros can only bail them out so much. Plus, the temptation to ship out some older players to recoup some assets may be tempting. Nashville could probably get a pretty big return for someone like O’Reilly, who will soon be 36 and is in the final year of his deal. A contending team would likely still give the Predators a couple of good young assets for him around the deadline. It would be shortsighted for MacFarland to not explore those types of moves, even if it hampers Nashville’s playoff chances this season.
Verdict: Pretender





